Social Security is Destroying America's Family Culture

Written by Marvin Olasky

Parents worked hard to provide for their children. When the parents could no longer work, the children provided for them. That was social security through the centuries. Given the vagaries of life it wasn’t always secure, but in general it worked—and when it did not, extended families, churches, and charitable ministries came alongside widows and orphans.

On April 15, 1912, the Titanic sank. The following year a constitutional amendment made possible the graduated income tax, and Congress set a top rate of 7 percent on incomes above $11 million (in 2012 dollars).

At first taxes were due in March, but in 1955 the due date moved to April 15—apparently for bureaucratic convenience, and not to equate the ship of state with another vessel once thought unsinkable. Titanic arrogance caused 1,517 deaths in 1912. A century later the Obama administration is taking us full speed ahead toward an iceberg of debt.

One strange aspect of the Titanic’s sinking: Morgan Robertson, 14 years before the great disaster, wrote Futility, a novel about the sinking of another enormous Atlantic liner. Robertson’s fictional ship had almost the same length and tonnage as the Titanic, with a high-society first-class passenger list and an insufficient number of lifeboats. Robertson had his ship striking an iceberg on a cold April night and sinking. The name of his fictional ship: the Titan.

No one, to my knowledge, has written a novel so prescient concerning our current, slow-motion economic disaster. Some say Ayn Rand did that with Atlas Shrugged, but she missed the connection between a biblical worldview and American economic success, and had her hero at book’s close making not the sign of the cross but (literally) the sign of the dollar. Her new economic order would have been built on sand.

Nor have the analyses I’ve seen of the crash of 2008 gotten causality right. Sure, politicians pressured bureaucrats who pressured bankers to loan money to people unlikely to pay it back. Sure, greed in high places and low played a big role. But I think the novel to describe how we’ve come to our present pass should have a historic title: Futility.

Here’s the plot of a new Futility: We used to have a virtuous cycle in Western culture. Parents worked hard to provide for their children. When the parents could no longer work, the children provided for them. That was social security through the centuries. Given the vagaries of life it wasn’t always secure, but in general it worked—and when it did not, extended families, churches, and charitable ministries came alongside widows and orphans.

A new Futility would show 20th-century government replacing children as the primary provider for those aged and needy. The change liberated elderly folks who were free to move away from their children, and often did. Florida or Arizona grew, but intergenerational contact tragically decreased. Another unanticipated effect: With Social Security, children became financially optional.

That change does not alter the goals of Christians and others who know the true value of children. Bible-believers give up some liberty—children restrict mobility and require responsibility—because we trust God when He says children are a blessing. Our chief purpose in life is to glorify God and enjoy Him forever (which begins right now), and children help us do both: Gifts from God, they bring parents joy.

That change does affect materialists. Some who could have children do not. Others stop at one. This has economic consequences: Yes, children are temporarily a money pit, but they are also a great incentive to work. Without that incentive many people work less and depend on the state to bail them out. Children are also an economic blessing to society as they grow and become creators.

A good novelist would show the psychological consequences of the change: Without an emphasis on work and family, many lack purpose. Some fill up the creeping days and weeks with experiences of different kinds, such as seeing new places and sexually seeking new people. Those who lose sight of eternity define a good life by consumption on earth—whoever gets the most toys wins—rather than preparation for heaven and the training of a new generation.

The novelist would show social consequences: We replace the virtuous cycle with a downward spiral. Fewer children means fewer workers to support the elderly. When some societies bring in more immigrants to do the work that the never-born members of the next generation would otherwise have done, additional tensions arise.

Politicians unveil plans to save Social Security, Medicare, and other programs. We need such plans, but without cultural renewal we can stamp all those plans: Futility.

Marvin Olasky is the editor-in-chief of WORLD Magazine.

@Copyright 2012 WORLD Magazine – used with permission

Posted in ,

Tony Locke

Live in Gwinnett, GA next to Lake Lanier Islands. Married with four children. Pastored three churches over 18 years. Spent time serving as an Army Chaplain. Traveled in ministry to over 34 countries. B.A., M.A., M.Div., M.A.T.S., D.Min. BCC with NSC. Covering Georgia and upstate South Carolina

2 Comments

  1. Anne Turner on July 14, 2012 at 6:32 am

    I am single, but strongly in favor of children. Single people are involved in many ways to support the children of all. I have not figured out why many vocal Christians believe it is holier to marry and have children in view of 1 Cor 7:32-34. Also, the Bible teaches that parents are to manage well in order to save for their children, not vice versa (2 Cor 12:14). If the opposite were true, children would be born for the purpose of their becoming slaves (as is currently true of many on welfare). To say this was always the plan up to April 15, 1912 is very far-fetched. To say “children are…a money pit” is very close to blasphemy. I have to say, this article is worldly.

  2. Anne Turner on July 15, 2012 at 8:53 am

    I posted that comment yesterday and came back today to see if I worded it too strongly. If we express what is on our mind, we may forget other directives, such as women not having a dominant posture toward men, so please forgive me if my comment strikes you in that way. One thing that came to my mind is the need for more teaching in the church on accepting payments from the government. Mr. Olasky is addressing an important topic, and I applaud him for that and would like to see more such explorations.

Leave a Comment





Young Pro-Marriage Conservatives Undaunted by the Battle Ahead

Young Pro-Marriage Conservatives Undaunted by the Battle Ahead

By ASHLEY PARKER WASHINGTON - They hear that their cause is lost, that demographics and the march of history have doomed their campaign to keep marriage only between a man and a woman. But the young conservatives who oppose same-sex marriage - unlike most of their generation - remain undaunted....
Which Politician Stood Before 65 Mill Viewers and Labeled Our National Debt Immoral?  — Revelation 11:15-19

Which Politician Stood Before 65 Mill Viewers and Labeled Our National Debt Immoral? — Revelation 11:15-19

(Thanks for sharing this sermon on Facebook over a 200 times!) by Reverend Anthony R. Locke Sermon Series in Revelation # 22 Preached on Pulpit Freedom Sunday 2012 Revelation 11:15-19 English Standard Version 15 Then the seventh angel blew his trumpet, and there were loud voices in heaven, saying, “The...
Why I Am Participating in Pulpit Freedom Sunday — Wayne Grudem

Why I Am Participating in Pulpit Freedom Sunday — Wayne Grudem

By Wayne Grudem The Speak Up Movement website This Sunday I have agreed to join nearly 1,500 pastors nationwide and participate in Pulpit Freedom Sunday, sponsored by Alliance Defending Freedom. In my sermon, I plan to recommend that people vote for one presidential candidate and one political party that I will...
Why Does Christmas Come Early for Those Who Hate God's Prophets? — Revelation 11:1-14

Why Does Christmas Come Early for Those Who Hate God's Prophets? — Revelation 11:1-14

"Two Prophets" by Antoon Van Dyck (1599-1641) by Reverend Anthony R. Locke Sermon Series in Revelation # 21 Revelation 11:1-14 English Standard Version 1   Then I was given a measuring rod like a staff, and I was told, “Rise and measure the temple of God and...
California Makes It Illegal to Try and Convert Gays Under the Age of 18

California Makes It Illegal to Try and Convert Gays Under the Age of 18

The Original AP Story SACRAMENTO, Calif. — California has become the first state to ban a controversial form of psychotherapy aimed at making gay teenagers straight. Gov. Jerry Brown announced Sunday that he had signed SB 1172 by Democratic Senator Ted Lieu of Torrance. The law, which prohibits sexual orientation...
The Powerful Legacy of William Tyndale

The Powerful Legacy of William Tyndale

by Reverend Anthony R. Locke Psalm 56:1-13 English Standard Version 1 To the choirmaster: according to The Dove on Far-off Terebinths. A Miktam of David, when the Philistines seized him in Gath. Be gracious to me, O God, for man tramples on me; all day long an attacker oppresses me;...